I paid that debt — it's still showing as owed

Here is the clock your letter is required to mention, spelled out.

And you are not alone in this, measured rather than said: 257 complaint narratives in the federal CFPB database mention a screening company alongside a paid debt still showing as owed.

Your FCRA deadlines, from your own date

The clocks are fixed: 60 days from the adverse action to request your free report copy, then 30 days for the screening company to conclude a dispute investigation — 45 days if you send additional information while it is running. Put the date on your denial letter in and get the actual dates.

Runs entirely in your browser — the date is never sent to us and never stored. General information based on FCRA consumer rights as explained in FTC and CFPB guidance, checked 2026-09-06. Your denial letter and the agencies' own pages govern your case.

You are in the right place
“Chex Systems shows I owe nothing, but a second report not mine with same name and SSN.”

We hear this most. a public complaint about ChexSystems, PissedConsumer, April 27, 2011 — from someone in the same position.

You have 60 days from the date on your letter to ask the screening company for a free copy of the report. Once you dispute something in it they get 30 days to investigate — 45 days if you send more evidence part-way through — and they have to correct or delete whatever they cannot verify.

The figure, how it was counted, and which companies it names are all in the block below.

CFPB published complaint narratives, 2011 - August 14, 2026. The CFPB ceased discretionary publication of complaint narratives on August 14, 2026, so every narrative-derived count on this site is a closed series and will not change. Complaint intake continues, and the per-company outcome table runs on all complaints and is current.

Get your own dates →

What to do tonight

Twenty minutes, at the kitchen table
  1. Find the proof you already own. A bank statement, a receipt, a settlement letter, a satisfaction of judgment. It is almost always already in your records, and it is stronger than anything you could buy.
  2. Request your free report copy so you can name the entry the way they print it — the amount, the date, and who reported it.
  3. Dispute in writing with a date in the sentence: “this balance was paid in full on [date],” proof attached. If a collection agency furnished it, dispute with the screening company anyway. The duty to investigate is theirs.

Every step above is free. The report copy and the dispute are both free under federal law, and anyone charging you for them is selling you a letter you can write yourself.

Free, and it stays free. Nothing on this page sits behind a payment, an account, or a form — and we never ask for your name, your Social Security number, or your case. The tools here run entirely in your browser; we never see your answers.

Paid collections that still show as open, rent balances cleared years ago, judgments satisfied but never updated — stale debt is one of the most common accuracy failures in screening reports, and one of the most fixable, because the paper trail is usually in your own records.

257
complaint narratives in the federal CFPB database mention a screening company alongside a paid debt still showing as owed (scan of 28.4 million rows, 2026-09-06)

The 3 companies most often behind this situation account for 189 of those 257 — 74%. Here is the full ranking across every company we publish.

Which companies these complaints name

ChexSystems
4,601 complaint mentions in total · dispute ignored or mishandled: 21
85
LexisNexis Risk Solutions
70,462 complaint mentions in total · dispute ignored or mishandled: 151
62
Early Warning Services
38,013 complaint mentions in total · dispute ignored or mishandled: 106
42
First Advantage
2,693 complaint mentions in total · dispute ignored or mishandled: 11
36
Checkr
2,575 complaint mentions in total · dispute ignored or mishandled: 7
17
AppFolio
289 complaint mentions in total · dispute ignored or mishandled: 0
4
SafeRent Solutions
128 complaint mentions in total · dispute ignored or mishandled: 1
4
HireRight
601 complaint mentions in total · dispute ignored or mishandled: 3
2
TransUnion Rental Screening
518 complaint mentions in total · dispute ignored or mishandled: 1
2
RealPage
20 complaint mentions in total · dispute ignored or mishandled: 1
1
RentGrow
15 complaint mentions in total · dispute ignored or mishandled: 0
1
CoreLogic Rental Property Solutions
13 complaint mentions in total · dispute ignored or mishandled: 0
1

How these are counted: a case-insensitive full-text scan of 28.4 million complaint rows in the federal CFPB Consumer Complaint Database (2026-09-06, files.consumerfinance.gov), counting rows that mention the company and the problem's keywords. These are complaint narratives that say it, not a census of everyone it happened to — the real number is higher, and a small figure here means few people wrote it down in those words, not that the problem is rare. Sterling is excluded pending harvest re-verification.

Your case is strong when

You have proof of payment: receipt, bank statement, settlement letter, or a satisfaction of judgment.

Evidence to gather

The longer version of that first move

Dispute in writing with the proof attached: identify the entry, state the debt was paid on [date], request the entry be updated or deleted. If a collection agency reported it, dispute with the screening company anyway — they carry the legal duty to investigate what they publish.

Copy-paste letters (fill in the brackets)

To get your free report — send to the screening company named in your denial letter (use the contact route on its official site or in the letter itself):

I was denied [housing / employment / a bank account] on [date] based on a consumer report you supplied. Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act I request my free copy of that report. My name: [full name]. Address: [address]. Date of birth: [DOB]. Please send it to the address above.

To dispute an error — send with copies (never originals) of your evidence:

I dispute the following item in my file: [describe the entry exactly as it appears]. It is inaccurate because [not mine / paid on date / dismissed by the court / wrong amount]. Enclosed: [list documents]. Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, please investigate and correct or delete this item, and send me the result in writing.

Keep a copy of everything you send, and send by a method you can prove (certified mail or the company's own dispute portal).

If you would rather not assemble it by hand: the Screening Dispute Kit (USD 39) writes the letter to the screening company and the one to whoever turned you down, dates your clock and gives you the CFPB text, in your browser. Everything above stays free.

What happens next, day by day

WhenWhat happensWhose move
Day 0Adverse action — you are denied, or offered worse terms, because of a consumer report. You must be told this happened and told which company supplied the report.The landlord, employer or bank
Days 0–60Request your free copy of that report from the screening company. Federal law says within 60 days of the adverse action. It is the actual report, not the landlord's summary.You
Day XRead it line by line against your own records and dispute every inaccurate item in writing, with copies of your evidence attached. The dispute is free.You
+30 daysThe screening company is generally required to investigate and to correct or delete what it cannot verify. Typically 30 days from receiving your dispute.The screening company
+45 daysThe same, extended, where you supplied additional information during the investigation.The screening company
AfterIf they verify something you know is wrong: add a statement of dispute to your file, complain free to the CFPB at consumerfinance.gov (companies must respond), and to your state attorney general.You

Every step above is free. Anyone charging you to exercise these rights is selling you a letter you can write yourself.

Where these dates come from, so you can check them yourself rather than take our word for it. 15 U.S.C. §1681j is the free-copy section: it gives you the report without charge if you ask within 60 days of the adverse-action notice, and one free file disclosure every 12 months besides. 15 U.S.C. §1681i is the dispute section: the screening company gets 30 days to reinvestigate, extended by up to 15 further days — 45 days in total — if you send relevant information while it is running. 15 U.S.C. §1681m is the notice section: the adverse-action notice you were sent is required to include an indication of that 60-day period. Plain-English versions of the same rules: FTC, free credit reports and FTC, disputing errors on your credit report.

Your three rights after a denial

Full plain-English walkthrough on our home page.

The amount is wrong but the debt is real — worth disputing?

Yes. Accuracy applies to every field. A $300 debt reported as $3,000 is an inaccuracy you can dispute, and the difference can change a screening decision.

Should I pay a credit repair company to do this?

No — the dispute is free and the evidence is already in your hands. Nobody can do it better than your own bank statement can.

What disputes can't do — and we won't help with

Disputes fix errors. They don't erase history that's true — accurate records survive investigation. If the record is real, what helps is settling and documenting it, second-chance programs, and time. We built this site for honest people hit by wrong records.

You know which piece of paper ends this, who has the legal duty to act on it, and that the duty sits with the company that published the entry, not with the collector who sold it.

If you take one thing from this page, take this: the letter is boring and it works, and the phone call is exhausting and it does not. A phone call leaves no record you can show. A short, dated, written dispute with copies attached puts a company on a clock it cannot quietly ignore, and it takes about twenty minutes at a kitchen table. You do not need to sound like a lawyer. You need to be specific about what is wrong and attach the proof.

— Andrew at Axion Labs. Write to me at hello@getaxionlabs.com if a page here is wrong or a step does not work. I read that inbox.

Screening companies relevant to this situation: lexisnexis risk · experian rentbureau · transunion rental. Based on FCRA consumer rights as explained in FTC and CFPB guidance, checked August 2026. General information, not legal advice. Free official complaint route: consumerfinance.gov.

Your words, in a box, read by a person. We ask for no name and no email.